Located at 1566 Benson Rd, Garner, NC 27529, United States, Carolina Fish Fry Co. stands as a welcoming destination for those who appreciate the timeless tradition of Southern-style seafood. Our establishment is built on a foundation of simple, honest cooking, where the focus remains entirely on the quality of the ingredients and the warmth of the hospitality we provide to every guest who walks through our doors. We believe that great food does not need to be complicated; it simply needs to be prepared with care, served fresh, and enjoyed in the company of friends and family.
Our kitchen operates with a deep respect for local culinary customs, ensuring that every plate reflects the authentic flavors that define our region. Whether you are a long-time resident of Garner or just passing through the area, we invite you to experience a meal that feels like a home-cooked tradition. We take pride in maintaining a clean, comfortable environment where the focus is on the dining experience and the satisfaction of our community. From the moment you arrive, our goal is to provide a consistent and enjoyable meal that highlights the best aspects of classic fish fry culture.
What Makes Our Kitchen Special
Commitment to Freshness: We prioritize sourcing quality ingredients to ensure that every dish meets our standards for taste and texture. Our preparation methods are designed to preserve the natural integrity of our seafood, resulting in a light, crispy finish that our regulars have come to expect.
Southern Hospitality: At Carolina Fish Fry Co., we treat every guest like a neighbor. Our service team is dedicated to creating a friendly and efficient atmosphere, making us an ideal spot for a casual lunch, a family dinner, or a quick bite during a busy day.
Community-Focused Atmosphere: Being part of the Garner community is central to our identity. We strive to be a reliable local staple where people can gather, share a meal, and enjoy the simple pleasures of well-prepared comfort food in a relaxed setting.
Consistent Culinary Standards: We focus on perfecting the classics. By refining our techniques over time, we ensure that the flavors you enjoy today are just as satisfying as the ones you experienced on your first visit, maintaining a level of quality that our patrons rely on.
A Tradition of Quality Dining
The philosophy at Carolina Fish Fry Co. is rooted in the belief that food should bring people together. By focusing on the fundamentals of seafood preparation and maintaining a welcoming environment at our Benson Road location, we aim to be a cornerstone of the local dining scene. We understand that our guests value reliability, flavor, and a genuine connection to the food they eat, which is why we remain dedicated to our craft every single day.
We invite you to visit us at 1566 Benson Rd to see for yourself why so many in the Garner area choose us for their seafood cravings. Whether you are looking for a hearty meal to share with your family or a satisfying plate to enjoy on your own, our doors are open. We look forward to serving you and continuing our tradition of providing quality, Southern-inspired seafood to our community for years to come. Thank you for making us a part of your dining journey and for supporting local businesses that care about the quality of every meal served.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating
Service options
Delivery
Drive-through
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in
Highlights
Serves local specialty
Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Offerings
Comfort food
Quick bite
Small plates
Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Table service
Amenities
Restroom
Atmosphere
Casual
Quiet
Crowd
Groups
Tourists
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu
Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking
Usually plenty of parking
Menus
Platters
Shrimp Platter$14.99
Flounder Platter$14.99
Catfish Platter$14.99
Fried Alaskan Platter$14.99
Fried Clam Strips Platter$14.99
Fried Deviled Crab Platter$17.99
Combine Any 2 Platters$17.99
Carolina Seafood Platters
Carolina Seafood Platter$27.59
Land Lovers
Pork Chop Sandwich With Fries$8.39
1/2 Lb. Double Cheeseburger With Fries$10.19
Hamburger Steak$13.19
Chicken Sandwich With Fries$8.99
Hand Breaded Chicken Tenders Basket$8.99
Pork Chop Platter$13.19
Drinks
20 Oz. Drink$3.59
Salads
Large House Salad$8.39
Side Salad$4.79
Large House Salad With Chicken Tenders$11.99
Large House Salad With Jumbo Shrimp$14.39
Baskets
Deviled Crab Basket$14.39
Fried Flounder Fillet Basket$11.39
Popcorn Shrimp Basket$11.39
Catfish Basket$11.39
Fried Jumbo Shrimp Basket$14.39
Clam Strips Basket$11.39
Fried Alaskan Fish Basket$11.39
Sides
Collards$3.00
Sweet Potato Fries$3.59
Potato Salad$2.49
Mashed Potatoes & Gravy$3.00
Coleslaw$3.00
Rice$1.99
French Fries$3.11
Mac & Cheese$3.99
Green Beans$3.00
Fried Okra$3.00
HushPuppies$2.49
Value Meals
Shrimp Burger$7.99
Fish Taco$6.79
Flounder Sandwich$7.99
Alaskan Fish Sandwich$7.99
Shrimp Taco$6.79
Extras
Extra Sauces$0.50
Carolina Po'boy Sandwiches
Fried Flounder Po'boy$9.59
Fried Alaskan Fish Po'boy$9.59
Shrimp Po'boy$9.59
Daily Specialty Platters
Jumbo Shrimp Platter$19.19
Scallops Platter$19.19
Tilapia Platter$16.79
Grilled Salmon Platter$19.19
Crab Cakes Platter$20.39
Photos
Reviews Carolina Fish Fry Co
MJ R
23-04-2026
If you're looking for a fish fry authentic to South Carolina with extremely fresh fish, extremely good customer service and a spotless restaurant owned by a family with 30 years of experience come here. Our first experience was exceptional. Thank you More
Gmanrocksteady G
23-04-2026
Wow, they have a great selection on the menu and they use fresh oil You can tell and it's delicious fried or grilled. And very reasonably priced. More
Josh Fowler
23-04-2026
Honestly just not good food. Like, at all. Unseasoned, green beans from a can with no seasoning, Alaskan fish was bland, salmon taco was soaking wet and salmon was overcooked. Really bad 1st impression, and unfortunately the last. If you … More
Robert Brinson
23-04-2026
Very good food and friendly staff! Your food is made fresh, and the portions are generous. The fried flounder baskets and kids popcorn shrimp basket were just the thing for my family's dinner, and the sweet tea was the perfect complement to our meal!
Tiffany
23-04-2026
I was already sketch about the food based off building and location but my fiancé always gives places a chance no matter what so we gave it a shot. The food was 4/10. The fish was salty, the mac was so basic & the shrimp were okay. The hush … More
Jennifer King
23-04-2026
The food was good but the service was better. Kendra and Nicole were pleasant and super hospitable. Thank you both for all that you do! More
Rasheeda Etheredge
23-04-2026
I'm new to the area from Georgia. I googled where to find a good shrimp po boy near me. I was not disappointed. Very tasty and fresh food for the price. Very good service and the restroom was very clean. This will definitely be my go to spot from now on. I highly reccomend this spot for a good meal without breaking the bank. More
LeslieAnn Klatt
23-04-2026
My husband and I stopped in here for an early dinner and it was pretty busy even though we weren’t there at peak hours. It was really good !! I had shrimp tacos ( fish 🐠 or shrimp tacos are one of my favorites) and these were the best I … More
Angela Gannon
23-04-2026
This seems to have gone downhill since they first opened. The service was great and the young lady at the drive thru was polite. The food on the other hand, meh. The oysters really didn’t have much oysters in the breading. The collards, cole slaw and okra were BLAND. I had to add some seasoning when I got home. More
Alison Delaney
23-04-2026
If you’re in the mood for quick seafood, this place comes through. Prices are reasonable (you get THREE sides) and the food is tasty. Service has always been swift and I’ve dined in as well as drive thru. Definitely recommend. More
Marcos Miranda
23-04-2026
I had the flounder and shrimp with hush puppies sweet potato fries and slaw. The restaurant was very clean staff was very nice and the food was prepared when ordered. I am a shrimp lover but I must say the flounder was the best thing on my plate today. Although the shrimp was good. I'll visit here again More
Arvian “Sparkles” Duval
23-04-2026
Review on December 19, 2024: 5 stars
We visited Carolina Fish fry yesterday to order three to-go plates. I always … More
Dee D
23-04-2026
Ordered through GrubHub so knew it might be cold due to the distance from my house. It wasn't hot but definitely not cold!! 😊 It was okay. I ordered the shrimp and flounder platter. Good size portions, but both were a little salty. Green beans however had no seasoning. Potato salad was pretty good. … More
Steve Karnes
23-04-2026
We had some delicious food from this place ! The drive thru line moved quickly. They have a great variety on their menu.
Our fish was perfectly prepared ! Best hush puppies ever ! … More
TD Crouse
23-04-2026
I cannot believe it took me so long to ever find this place. Today’s special was whole Red Snapper, and it was delightful! I have enjoyed the flounder, and shrimp here as well. The sides are Southern Style, and authentic. I now have it pinned in my favorite places. More
Steve Beane
23-04-2026
Great fish sandwich, terrific service
Pictured is the flounder sandwich (far) and the Alaskan fish sandwich (near) More
Ray Gravis
23-04-2026
Very nice place. Food was really good. Portion size was very generous. Service was excellent! Highly recommend! More
Lee Gearheart
23-04-2026
We were planning on going to mayflower for supper but we ended up on this side of town. What a great choice. Service was impeccable the food was even better. I was amazed how good the food was. Me and my wife came in with not high … More
LonnieD
23-04-2026
The first impression was the person taking the orders. Really needs to be friendlier. Didn't say one word during the whole order. The food was a mixed experience. The fried popcorn shrimp and claim strips had no flavor except for the … More
M CG
23-04-2026
Carolina Fish Fry Company was just okay. It didn’t really wow me. I ordered the seafood platter and swapped the popcorn shrimp for jumbo shrimp, which cost a little extra, and I also got a sweet tea. … More
Reviews Carolina Fish Fry Co